Buy Finished or Renovate? How Jupiter and Tequesta Buyers Decide

by Matthew Pfohl

Finished home or a project? In Jupiter and Tequesta, the answer starts with the week you want, not the house.

If you want tee times and boat days to start this season, buy finished. If  you can live elsewhere while the work happens and you want the home built around how you live, a renovation can make sense. Here is what decides it on the ground.

The real trade: time, money, certainty

A finished home costs more on day one and gives you the most certainty. A project costs less to buy and adds permits, inspections, contractor schedules and rules you don't control. Neither is wrong. The mistake is pricing the house without pricing the process.

Inventory is tight right now. In Q3 2026, the Town of Jupiter recorded 2.8 months of single-family supply, and homes went under contract in a median 26 days. The Village of Tequesta recorded 2.7 months of supply, though with only 12 sales that number is a direction, not a rule. (Florida REALTORS, Palm Beach County Local Market Metrics, single-family homes, Q3 2026, released Oct 16, 2026.) Fewer finished homes to choose from is one reason buyers widen the search to homes that need work.

Permits: expect one for almost everything

Town of Jupiter. All construction in the Town requires a permit, and applications go through the Town's online portal. Electrical, mechanical, plumbing, roofing, driveway, fence and pool work each need their own permit. Window and door replacements are permitted like for like, and changing an opening's size or location takes an alteration permit. Projects over $5,000 need a recorded Notice of Commencement.

Village of Tequesta. The Village takes permit applications online, and it says plan reviews are usually completed within five business days. If the home is in an HOA, the Village needs the HOA's written approval before it issues a window or door permit.

The Town of Jupiter does not publish typical review times, so build slack into any timeline.

Wind: plan for impact protection

Both the Town of Jupiter and the Village of Tequesta design homes for a 170 mph wind speed (Risk Category II). Replacement windows and doors need approved products. In this area, glass openings must be impact-resistant or protected by impact-rated shutters. It is one of the larger line items in a renovation, and one of the best for insurance and peace of mind.

Flood zones and the 50% rule

If a home sits in a flood zone, one number shapes the whole plan. When the cost of improvements equals or exceeds 50% of the structure's market value before the work, that is a "substantial improvement." The building must then be brought up to current flood requirements. In Palm Beach County, substantially improved structures are held to the same elevation standards as new construction.

Since 2025, Florida law has barred local governments from adding up improvements over several years to reach that 50%. Ask the building department how it calculates the threshold today before you set a budget.

Roof age and insurance

Under Florida law, an insurer may not refuse to write or renew a homeowner's policy solely because the roof is under 15 years old. For a roof 15 years or older, you can order an inspection at your own expense. If it shows at least five years of useful life left, the insurer may not refuse coverage solely because of age. (Section 627.7011(5), Florida Statutes.) Get a roof and four-point picture before you price a project. It changes the math fast.

Taxes: what resets, and what Amendment 3 changes

In Florida, a home is reassessed at full market value the year after it sells. Plan your carrying costs on the purchase price, not the seller's tax bill.

Amendment 3 passed on Nov 3, 2026 and takes effect on Jan 1, 2027. It does not change 2026 tax bills. It does two things:

  • Second homes and rentals. The yearly limit on increases in assessed value for non-homestead property drops from 10% to 5%, for non-school taxes.
  • Primary homes. The non-school homestead exemption rises to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028.

The new amounts first appear on the August 2027 proposed tax notices. If you are moving from a Florida homestead, portability can carry up to $500,000 of your Save Our Homes benefit to the new home. You must establish the new homestead within three years of January 1 of the year you gave up the old one.

The state's My Safe Florida Home program has offered hardening grants for windows, doors and roofs. Check current availability at mysafeflhome.com before you count on it.

When renovating makes sense, and when it doesn't

  • It can make sense when the location is the hard part to find (the water, the club, the street), the structure is sound, the home sits outside the flood zone or well below the 50% line, and you have a place to live while the work happens.
  • Think twice when the plan pushes past the 50% threshold in a flood zone, the roof and windows both need replacing on top of the "fun" work, or you need the home ready for this season.

How we walk a property

We start with our Lifestyle Valuation checklist: how the home supports the week you want, from the water and the club to the walk and the commute. Then we look at the things that move a renovation budget, including flood zone, roof age, window protection, permits and HOA rules. Sometimes the honest answer is to keep looking.

Explore ownership and investment with us, read our Amendment 3 guide, or see buying a second home in Jupiter.

This is general information, not legal, tax, insurance or construction advice. Confirm the details with the building department, your insurance agent and your tax advisor.

Live with intention. Start a conversation.

Sources